If you’ve devoured The Summer I Turned Pretty trilogy, chances are you’re still replaying the love triangle in your head: Belly, Conrad, and Jeremiah. Team Jeremiah fans especially know the rollercoaster ride—sweet moments, heartbreaking twists, and the ultimate question: Who does Jeremiah end up with in the books?
This post is for fans who are obsessed with every little detail of Jenny Han’s trilogy, the kind who pause to scream at the page, highlight their favorite lines, and argue on TikTok about who’s better for Belly. Let’s walk through Jeremiah’s journey, what happens in the novels, and why his ending still sparks so much debate.
Jeremiah’s Role in Belly’s Love Story
Jeremiah Fisher isn’t just a side character. He’s funny, dependable, and for a lot of fans, the healthier option for Belly compared to his brooding older brother, Conrad.
-
He’s the sunshine to Conrad’s storm.
-
He’s the one Belly always thought would never hurt her.
-
And yet, the trilogy proves even Jeremiah has flaws—and big ones.
That’s what makes him relatable. Readers see him as the “boy-next-door” type, but Jenny Han makes sure his arc feels real, not perfect.
The Big Question: Who Does Jeremiah End Up With?
Here’s the answer fans always want straight up:
In Jenny Han’s The Summer I Turned Pretty trilogy, Jeremiah does not end up with Belly.
By the end of the third book (We’ll Always Have Summer), Belly chooses Conrad, and they marry. Jeremiah, heartbroken but matured, steps back from the love triangle.
So, technically? Jeremiah doesn’t end up with anyone in the books. His story closes with him moving forward, learning from mistakes, and leaving room for the idea that his future love story just hasn’t been written yet.
Why Belly Didn’t Choose Jeremiah
This is where fans split into two camps:
Team Jeremiah’s Case
-
He was there for Belly when Conrad shut her out.
-
He offered stability and lightheartedness.
-
Their relationship, for a while, looked like the dream “best friends to lovers” story.
But the Problem
-
Jeremiah betrayed Belly’s trust at college—something that shook their foundation.
-
His love was real, but at times it felt like he was clinging to not lose her rather than fully honoring who she was becoming.
That’s why Belly ultimately realized her heart belonged to Conrad, even if Jeremiah seemed like the “safe” choice.
What Jeremiah’s Ending Really Means
For Jeremiah fans, the ending stings. But it’s not really a loss—it’s growth. Jenny Han doesn’t box him into “the rejected brother.” Instead:
-
He learns from heartbreak.
-
He accepts that sometimes love means letting go.
-
He gets the chance to write his own story beyond Belly.
For readers, this makes Jeremiah one of the most real characters. Haven’t we all had moments where the person we thought was “the one” ended up being just a chapter, not the whole book?
Why Jeremiah’s Journey Still Matters to Fans
Fans keep asking “Who does Jeremiah end up with?” because it’s not just about shipping—it's about closure.
-
If you’re Team Jeremiah, you wanted to see him happy, not just walking away.
-
If you’re Team Conrad, Jeremiah’s heartbreak made Belly’s final choice more satisfying.
-
Either way, Jeremiah’s arc resonates because it mirrors real-life first loves: sweet, complicated, and not always forever.
Final Thoughts: Team Jeremiah Deserves Hope
So, Jeremiah doesn’t end up with Belly in the books. But that doesn’t mean his story is sad. Instead, Jenny Han leaves his future wide open. Maybe that’s her way of saying: Jeremiah’s happily-ever-after is still coming—just not in this trilogy.
And honestly? That might be the most realistic love story of all.
Call-to-Action
Are you Team Jeremiah or Team Conrad? Drop your thoughts below and let’s settle this once and for all! And if you’re re-reading the series, share your favorite Jeremiah moment—because this boy deserves his flowers.